No taxation without representation

2023-01-03 11:21≈ 503Words≈ 3Minutes

East and West, ancient and modern—the “money” governments and people fight over, even to war, is tax.

When total taxes are so high the poor cannot survive, Chinese peasants rebel; in Western history, procedural questions—who may tax, what tax is for, how to tax—are often more fundamental than the rate. Political wars over taxing power are history Chinese still find unfamiliar.

In a sense, wars over taxing power opened the door to modern constitutional government.

Taxing power means the source of authority to tax. In modern systems it is the legislature in an elected government, because it represents voters. Only voters decide whether to give part of their money to the state for public spending; only their elected representatives may act for them; only representatives may deliberate rates, categories, amounts, and collection per voters’ will; only lawful executive organs created by statute may enforce tax law.

Those powers in exercise and afterward are still subject to public opinion and judicial oversight and review, which finally settles legitimacy of authority and propriety of exercise.

No taxation without representation

No taxation without representation, from the 1750s–1760s, first voiced by Jonathan Mayhew.

It summed colonists’ grievances and was a main cause of the American Revolution.

In short, many colonists held that because they had no direct representation in Parliament, any colonial tax law Parliament passed (Sugar Act, Stamp Act, etc.) was unconstitutional under the 1689 Bill of Rights and denied rights due them as British subjects.

In the revolutionary era, only one in twenty British subjects had a seat in Parliament—and none from the colonies.

Today similar slogans are used by various groups in various countries, including in some US locales.

Constitution of the People’s Republic of China

Chapter III State organs

Article 59 The National People’s Congress is composed of deputies elected from provinces, autonomous regions, municipalities directly under the central government, special administrative regions, and the armed forces. Ethnic minorities shall have appropriate representation.

Election of NPC deputies is conducted by the NPC Standing Committee.

NPC deputy quotas and election methods are prescribed by law.

Article 97 Deputies to people’s congresses of provinces, municipalities directly under the central government, and cities divided into districts are elected by the people’s congress at the next level below; deputies to people’s congresses of counties, cities not divided into districts, municipal districts, townships, ethnic townships, and towns are elected directly by voters.

Under the constitution, our supreme state organ is elected by the NPC; the NPC is elected by provinces, regions, municipalities, SARs, and the military; those bodies’ deputies come from county-level direct elections. In theory, if every level worked, bottom-up election of people’s congress deputies could happen.

In practice, among 1.4 billion people (if there are still 1.4 billion), how many have seen a ballot? How many know who represents them?

In that case, why should I pay tax to strangers who decide how my money is spent?

If you are my representative and you see this, contact me—I have opinions I need you to convey upward.