Bad habits of dictatorial governments
Lately I feel more and more disgusted by his techniques for ruling the people— yet I still have to admire it: he really has ordinary people figured out. Overseas “anti-China forces” should stop saying he is uncultured. He really is learning from the ancestors— he just picked up half a jar of water and shakes it all day long.
Qin Shi Huang’s five techniques for governing the people
Amusingly, “five techniques for governing the people” was deleted from Baidu Baike—ha ha ha ha
The five techniques for governing the people are recorded in the Book of Lord Shang. We all learned in history that Qin grew strong starting with Shang Yang’s reforms, but teachers never mentioned Shang Yang’s core five techniques—I guess Yuan Tengfei might enjoy talking about them.
The Book of Lord Shang lists five techniques: Unifying the people: unify thought, monopolize ideology, implement policies to keep the masses ignorant. Weakening the people: weak people, strong state; strong state, weak people—the way to govern is to weaken the people. Exhausting the people: find busywork for the people so they run ragged without rest, then the ruler rests easy; endless wars—draftees, regular troops, border garrisons; endless corvée—labor, miscellaneous labor, military labor—so people have no time for anything else. Humiliating the people: keep them crawling for a living, without dignity or confidence; egg them on to inform on each other, living forever in fear. Impoverishing the people: beyond bare survival, strip surplus grain and wealth; poor in spirit, thin in flesh—dependence on what the state doles out or starvation. If the five fail, kill.
Shang Yang believed: whoever rules the realm must first rule the people! We are like animals in a ready-made cage; every move is a performance others want. The cage-holder fears your idleness—idle enough for self-reflection, desire, and taste; idle enough for analysis and dissection—how rebellious! The sage said long ago: “Let the people follow the path; do not let them know why.”
Emperor Wu of Han’s “three policies connecting heaven and man”
Qin could push the five techniques because it was still moving from slavery toward feudalism—the people were dull and travel and communication were hard. Even so, the five techniques were a double-edged sword: extreme power put Qin’s king, scholar-officials, and common people in outright opposition, and in the end the blame fell on Shang Yang and he was torn apart by five chariots.
So Dong Zhongshu proposed the three policies connecting heaven and man to Emperor Wu. Core points:
Resonance between heaven and man, divine right of kings: set up a spiritual emperor so common people have faith; that spiritual emperor cannot err, and Wu’s power comes from him—cutting off dissent, same idea as religion later. Elevate Confucius, suppress other schools: obsequious Confucians cut and paste for the throne into a castrated mainstream that flatters the ruling class, unifying and imprisoning thought. Great unity of the Spring and Autumn Annals, honor the king and expel the barbarians: manufacture foreign threats to shift internal contradictions. Establish the Imperial Academy: reform talent selection; oppose hereditary office—scholars all become the Son of Heaven’s disciples.
Then even if people thought Wu was wrong, by the first point Wu might err but the god would not—so no rebellion. Later Wu’s Edict of Repentance at Luntai in 89 BCE admitted mistakes and won hearts back.
The Great Leader’s “mobilize the masses to struggle against the masses”
I first heard this phrase in elementary school. A classmate named Tengda—I forget the incident—argued with the teacher; the teacher said everyone who agreed raise your hand, disagreeents don’t. Nobody raised a hand. Little fat Tengda slammed the door on his way out and yelled at the teacher: “You’re mobilizing the masses to struggle against the masses—you’re Mao in the Cultural Revolution!” Imagine—fifth grade. I was delighted inside and remember it to this day.
He always likes to escalate issues so he can split the masses—pull one faction, hit another. Today use this group to hit that one, tomorrow the reverse. A small handful today, another tomorrow—add up to a big batch. He uses feudal emperor tactics not only to make cadres fight cadres and masses fight masses, but armies fight armies and Party members fight Party members. Manufacture contradiction and division to divide and conquer and keep power.
He knows attacking everyone at once is suicide, so today pull A to hit B, tomorrow pull B to hit A. Each period he ropes in one force to crush another. Today honeyed words for those he pulls in; tomorrow trumped-up charges and death. Today honored guests, tomorrow prisoners.
He is a paranoia of suspicion and cruelty. His philosophy of purging is no half measures. Everyone he purges must be destroyed utterly, and he pins all the dirt on others. In plain words, the people who fall like figures on a revolving lantern are all his scapegoats.
Someone’s half jar of water
So all this talk of anti-corruption is nonsense. Fine—go anti-corruption; the goal is not real anti-corruption anyway. Afterward the money still won’t come to me, and we can stop the performance—it is annoying to watch.
He lacks the Great Leader’s prestige, the Second Leader’s vision, or the Wen–Jing era’s magnanimity—like a rich kid propped up to run a company after the chairman died: ambition sky-high, no real strategy in his chest, obstinate and suspicious, wanting to control everything, good at nothing; when the company is about to fail, “Fine, I won’t manage it—you figure it out.”
I want to say: if you wear the crown, bear its weight. Nobody forced you to sit there; if the pressure is too much, step down.
Recent routines are so laughable you want to punch someone:
- Since November the pandemic was already out of control—three years in, if you truly lose control you are no longer great, glorious, and correct.
- Local government finances are very tight; more lockdowns might touch stability-maintenance money—that absolutely cannot be touched.
- The whole country is furious about the big fire—perfect excuse to roll off the slope. Full opening will mean mass infection so opinion can be steered: blame the coexistence camp while he stays correct.
- Full opening will kill people at a ratio—especially very high among those over 70. If they all die, great—save pension payouts.
- A sharp U-turn will squeeze hospitals and drugs—another windfall. You won’t buy homes, cars, or consume? You’ll buy medicine—at least half a year.
- I have no energy left to rant. Whatever.
